One 1-ton jacketed tank. Inner diameter from 1070 to 1055, length from 1155 to 1125.
The bottom head went from 10T to 8T, and material dropped by 14.5 kg.
Capacity is still 1 ton, working volume unchanged. All that changed was a few millimeters of size.
The required thickness from the calculation changes continuously, down to the decimal. But the plate you actually buy comes in steps: 6, 8, 10, 12. If the requirement is 8.2, you use 10T. If it is 7.9, you use 8T. The difference is 0.3 mm, but the plate is a whole step apart.
So within the same capacity there is a size that sits just above a step. Shrink the inner diameter a little, lengthen a little to keep the capacity, and the required thickness drops below the step. The 1-ton tank above was standing on exactly that spot.
Every designer knows this spot exists. The problem is the time it takes to find it. Step the inner diameter down by 5 mm, and at each diameter try the lengths that keep the capacity in 5 mm steps — even a 1-ton tank gives 45 combinations. A large tank gives hundreds. Each combination means recalculating shell, heads and jacket, and after that the drawing and the plate list change again.
So most tanks go out at the size the first calculation produced. Not for lack of knowledge — for lack of time to check them all by hand.
Size search (SWEEP) in AUTONEST VC gives up capacity within a set range (5% by default) and runs every one of those combinations. Below are actual run records. No currency is shown — material prices and fabrication rates differ from company to company, so thickness and weight are where design's answer ends.
| Tank | Before | After | Material |
|---|---|---|---|
| Jacketed 1 ton | ID 1070 · L 1155 · bottom head 10T | ID 1055 · L 1125 · bottom head 8T | −14.5 kg |
| Jacketed 10 ton | ID 2300 · bottom head 32T | ID 2225 · bottom head 30T | −64.5 kg |
| Jacketed 2 ton | ID 1345 · shell 8T | ID 1315 · shell 6T | −48.8 kg |
| Jacketed 2.5 ton | ID 1450 · shell 8T | ID 1420 · shell 6T | −112.8 kg |
The inner diameter shrank by only 2–3%, and one part dropped a full step. The drawing is redrawn at the new size, and the plate list and weld map follow.
This part has to be said plainly. Size search does not always produce a saving.
When there is no gain, the program leaves the original size untouched. It does not force a change. If you run with search on and the result matches the first run, that tank simply wasn't standing on a step. That is also an answer.
Whether 5% of capacity can be given up is the designer's call. Set the range to 0 and search is off; set it to 5% and it searches only within that. How much to give up is the input; finding the step inside it is the program's job.
This was never a spot designers couldn't find. It was a spot they skipped because there was no time to check. When that check finishes in about a minute, every tank that used to go out at its first size becomes a candidate for review.
Related — The plate got heavier, yet the total went down · "A three-tonne one" does not contain any dimensions · Internal pressure: seconds. External pressure: 5 minutes.