Calculate one jacketed vessel and the report comes out at more than thirty pages. Shell internal pressure, shell external pressure, top and bottom heads, jacket, closure, nozzles, flanges, sight glasses, relief devices, the welding map, the material list — every one of them needed. And yet the page a reviewer opens first is one of them.
That page is the SUMMARY. This is the story of how that one page was put together.
The order is the review order.
This is the part that got the most attention. There are seven tables, and one way of reading them.
Item → condition → value used → value required → verdict
Whichever table you are looking at, that is the order.
| Table | Value used | Value required | Verdict |
|---|---|---|---|
| Body (shell · heads · jacket) | thickness used | internal-pressure thickness · allowable external pressure | PASS |
| Jacket closure | thickness used · width used | allowable width | PASS |
| Nozzles | thickness | required area · effective area | PASS |
| Flanges | thickness used | calculated thickness | PASS |
| Sight glasses | thickness used | calculated thickness | PASS |
| Relief devices | effective discharge | required discharge | PASS |
| Nozzle closures | thickness used | allowable external pressure | PASS |
Nozzles are judged on area and relief devices on discharge rate. Different physical quantities. But the skeleton is kept identical — put what was used next to what was required, and rule on it.
So a reviewer never has to learn a new way of reading for each table. Running down the rightmost column alone tells you whether the vessel passes, and if a line catches your eye you trace that one line back to the left.
If there is one nozzle, the nozzle table is one row. If no sight glass was fitted, the sight glass table is not shown at all. In the report measured for this article, 78 rows were collapsed.
The reason for not leaving blanks is simple. A blank looks like "not filled in yet". The reviewer stops at it, asks, and waits for an answer. For something that was never used, absent is better for everyone.
Conversely, when a value should be there and is missing, that does not pass. If there is no number the verdict is not left blank either — it is left as NOT OK. An invisible pass is the dangerous one.
A summary that is only a summary cannot be reviewed. If the answer to "why is this thickness 3 mm" is not there, that page is just an assertion.
So every line on the SUMMARY has its own calculation sheet behind it. Shell internal pressure, shell external pressure, heads, jacket, closure, each nozzle, each flange — all attached as tabs in the same file. Items that require reading a chart, such as external pressure, even include the actual chart with the point that was read marked on it.
The one page is the page you read first, not the page you read instead. Someone in a hurry finishes there; someone who wants to check has to be able to go down from that spot.
People who receive a strength report are usually short of time. They skim it before sending it up, before sending it to the buyer, and once more before inspection. Nobody reads thirty pages each time.
What they need at that moment is one thing — where is this tight? If that is not visible on one screen, the person ends up opening each sheet and building the summary in their head. And that summary is not kept. The next person builds it again.
So that summary was put inside the report, instead of being rebuilt by a person every time. One page holds the whole thing, and if you want the basis you can go down to it from there.